141 Views | 11 Comments

Fringe Division — Some Thoughts On The Imminent Dota 2

Fringe Division — Some Thoughts On The Imminent Dota 2

Having been an avid DotA player on Twilight for many years, I’ve always wondered how long DotA and particularly the Twilight server would last. Would people ever lose interest in the game? Well that’s clearly not happening, however a death blow might be coming in the form of Dota 2.

The Warcraft 3 engine is beginning to show its strain in its limitations, understandably since it’s now over a decade old. Many DotA clones have emerged and have captured pieces of the market, HoN and LoL just to name a couple. However Twilight and DotA have stood strong since HoN and LoL both deviated from the exact mechanics of DotA and gamers REALLY don’t like a new learning curve. Dota 2, the REAL successor, will no doubt capture the largest portion of the market once it is officially released to everyone.

Its barrier to entry is extremely low since the game is going to be free to play and the revenue model is only for aesthetics. The game play is identical to DotA which should also ease in those DotA die-hards. However it is still a learning curve. Learning the looks of the heroes, items and spells does take a few games, but getting back into the swing of things doesn’t take long. The shop I’ll admit was difficult to adjust to and I really hated it at first. But once you work with the conveniences it affords you instead of looking through items manually, it gets a lot better.

Of course there will be some hold outs. People don’t like change, so some will hold out purely on resistance to change, others will hold out since they’re disadvantaged when it comes to computer hardware. Many local players are going to feel the frustration of going from a big fish in a little pond to a little fish in a very big pond.

I do however think that the local Twilight server just might lose its critical mass once Dota 2 gains full traction after launch. It would be sad to see it end up a ghost town, but the times they are a changing. I think the Twilight server has been of great service to the SA gaming community over the years and it would be a shame to see it fall into disuse.

I do however hope that a local server for Dota 2 gets hosted (maybe a WAGE) so that we can not only get better latency, but also maintain some form of this local community spirit. Because quite frankly I’m sick of playing with Russians.

If You Liked This, You Should Try These!

Name: Matthew Slade
Location: Cape Town
Position: Columnist, Mobile

  • kluch

    Only reason we need a local server is to keep the local baddies (ZA Russians)  here and not on the EU server.

  • http://twitter.com/Weeman360 Weeman360

    Good article. I completely agree

  • NeoN

    I’ve been jamming Dota 2 for a few of weeks now and I gotta admit I won’t be returning to DotA (1), unless it’s for a LAN comp.

    My thanks goes out to the guyz working behind the scenes who’ve run the Twilight server for all these years. You’ve provided countless awesome memories. m(_ _)m

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Michael-Matthee/684016860 Michael Matthee

    It is completely true. I Have been playing Dota2 for a while now and my only issue is the latency. Game would start perfect and 5 minutes in the delay starts for some reason. When the game finishes I head back to my twilight account.
    Valve would benifit alot from using a South African company as a server, then we can against the internationals with no problem at all! Even if twilight wants to go in to partnership with them, or as the articacle stated, WAGE. I saw that WAGE runs the Borderlands server on steam, so why not just take one for the team and set up a Dota2 server?
    @702b5067c1aa01ff0ef68672926e8613:disqus , you are on the ball. I’ve been with the twilight server since the days before Nitrate, through the days where Scant went on his rants and rampages. Been awesome guys!
    So let’s see where this can take us, because I have to agree, Dota2 is the future. It’s still the same yet more SHINY:)

    • http://twitter.com/Weeman360 Weeman360

      “Valve would benifit alot from using a South African company as a server, then we can against the internationals with no problem at all!”

      No offense (no really), but I don’t think you understand how servers work. If we get a local server, we would only be playing with people playing on our server. International people wouldn’t join our server because then they would get bad latency.

  • Cloud Strife

    I have no lag when playing Dota 2 (sits at about 200 lat). But yes…the russians are a pain, they need to go..

    Otherwise, thanks Twilight, its been great fun and I still frequent the server with friends from time to time.

    • http://twitter.com/MatuMikey Michael Matusowsky

      200ms and you don’t notice delay? Are you like 90 years old? I start noticing a delay in response at 150ms in DotA. Fact of the matter is, for an A-RTS, a delay of 100ms is like the absolute maximum you should ever get to play well. In an FPS it’s below 50ms.

    • http://egamer.co.za/author/cavie Caveshen “CaViE” Rajman

       But have you played Dota 2? Even with up to a 250ms latency, it works very smoothly. Agreed though. It’s only slightly noticeable but a keen sense WILL spot such a difference.

    • kluch

      ITT: Baddies making excuses about delay

  • Gest

    Will not play D2 until there is a south african server. The delay is very annoying, as are the 200mb weekly updates :/

  • Strider

    So much drivel from people who don’t know what they’re talking about (in reference to the comments, not the article).

    I don’t read egamer much, but when I do, I only read cavie articles <3